The year was 1994. I was a college freshman, and I had a thought while sitting bored in my dorm: Does my pepper spray really work? So I pressed the lever… and the spray quickly filled the room, entered the ventilation system, and invaded the rooms of every girl on the 2nd floor. And because of my decision, everyone was evacuated…blergh.
Oftentimes, one action, attitude or belief can permeate almost everything we do and spread in ways that we cannot control. For me, this pervasive attitude, or the “pepper spray” in my life, is perfectionism.
My favorite definition of perfectionism comes from author and research professor Brené Brown.
She defines perfectionism as a “way of thinking and feeling that says if I look perfect, do it perfect, work perfect, and live perfect, I can avoid or minimize shame, blame or judgment.” Brown says that “When perfectionism is driving, shame is always riding shot gun and fear is the annoying backseat driver.”
And for those of us who have lived it, we know exactly what she’s talking about. But I’m discovering that my perfectionism doesn’t just affect me, it impacts the people in my sphere of influence, especially my friends. Here are the four ways that my desire to be perfect affects my friendships.
Way #1: I create a mask to cover my flaws.
Here’s what I do: Outside of my make-up, I cover up by wearing a mask that says, “Move along, nothing to see here.” Brown says that we carry perfection around “hoping it will keep us from being hurt. In truth, it keeps us from being seen.”
Emily P. Freeman outlines several masks in Grace for the Good Girl:
* Good-performance
* Fake “fine”
* Always-serving
* Good Christian/rule-following
* Strength and responsibility
* Keeping everyone happy
* “I don’t care”
Here’s how it impacts friendship: I’m missing out on real connection because I won’t ever take off my mask to share a struggle or sin. You may either be attracted to my perfection while I hold you at arm’s length, or you may be repelled when you sense the fake or when you think you’ll never compare with my facade.
Here’s what God says: God is our fortified tower, and I’m safe when I run to Him (Proverbs 18:10). I’m not safe behind the mask I’ve constructed—I’m exhausted. God calls us to be real, not ideal. He calls us to confession and community, not idealized isolation.
How to shift away: I personally started by asking God what mask I’m hiding behind… which is, like, all of them. Then I asked Him to show me a new way because I really didn’t know what to do without my mask. I trust that He is good and faithful to take the mask(s) that we offer Him and to comfort and show us who we really are.
Way #2: I’m so self-sufficient that I don’t need your help.
Here’s what I do: As an Achiever, I believe that asking for help is weakness, so I don’t do it.
Here’s how it impacts friendship: Not accepting help fuels our pride, and it robs other people of the joy that they could experience by helping us. Friendship is designed to be a give-and-take. So if I only give, I create an imbalanced and unhealthy dynamic between us.
Here’s what God says: At His core, our God is a generous giver. He gives life (Psalm 18:35), the desires of our hearts (Psalm 31:4), grace (Ephesians 1:7–8), love (Jeremiah 31:3), and His only Son (John 3:16).
How to shift away: This one is both easy and hard—we have to ask for help and then receive it. It starts with naming our need, and recognizing that we have limits. Need a deadline extension? Ask. Is the thought of cleaning the house leaving you overwhelmed? Hire a housekeeper even if it’s just for one clean.
Way #3: I believe that my perfectionism only impacts me.
Here’s what I do: I say that my perfectionism only pertains to me, but if I’m honest, it leaks out to others. I assume that my friends hold the same expectations that I do, and I think that they should always meet our standards.
Here’s how it impacts friendship: When our friends fail to meet our arbitrary (although very real and important to us) expectations, we can struggle to forgive them. When unmet expectations happen consistently, we can shut down altogether.
Here’s what God says: Friends, read this verse as if it’s a guide on how to treat yourself: “Be kind and compassionate to one another, forgiving each other, just as in Christ, God forgave you.” (Ephesians 4:32) Did you catch it? Be kind to yourself. Be compassionate to yourself. Forgive yourself if you made a mistake. Remember that your expectations drive you, but your Good Shepherd leads you. If your expectations are practical and reasonable but your friend still lets you down, forgive. I didn’t say to be a doormat, but your job is still to forgive.
How to shift away: Take those expectations to Jesus, and ask: Are these Your expectations of me and my friends or are they self-imposed? Where did they come from? Do I still need to hold on to them? God may tell you that those expectations are all on you, and it’s time to let them go.
Personally, this is a hard one for me. My expectations define my identity, so letting go of them means losing a piece of me. I must remember that my identity is in Christ. When a self-imposed expectation pops up, offer grace to yourself, and to your friends, when it’s not met.
Way #4: Conditions must be ideal for me to connect.
Here’s what I do: I believe that connection happens when I have the perfect amount of time and a perfectly-clean house.
Here’s how it impacts friendship: We don’t connect because we never have enough time or our house has toys on the floor while the home of our fellow-perfectionist friend doesn’t even have lint on the baseboards. We feel like we can’t compare, so we don’t even try.
Here’s what God says: God will always give us the perfect conditions to do what He has asked us to do, which doesn’t necessarily translate to our to-do list. God can stretch time. Jesus tells us how to have ideal conditions in John 8:28–29: “I do nothing on My own initiative, but I speak these things as the Father taught Me. And He who sent Me is with Me; He has not left Me alone, for I always do the things that are pleasing to Him.” Let’s focus less on having ideal conditions, and let’s listen more to what God’s asking of us—I guarantee it’s loving on His people.
How to shift away: Look for partial solutions. For example, my best friend and I often talk while we’re in the pick-up line for school. We may have only eight minutes, but I’ll take eight minutes of laughter and memories over eight minutes of scrolling through Facebook. Instead of a perfectly-clean house, allow yourself to have a cereal box left on the counter when your guests arrive.
Just like that pepper spray from all those years ago, perfectionism impacts many aspects of our friendships: the intimacy level, our ability to receive, our standards, and our connection. While I couldn’t put the pepper spray back in the bottle, you now have tools to curb your perfectionism so that your friendships become one of the most vital and healthy parts of who you are.
My dear friend Melody gave me this advice, “You don’t have to be perfect. You just need to trust me with your imperfections.” Now that’ll preach.
If you’ve been encouraged by what you’ve read, consider subscribing by adding your email to the box in the top right corner. Already a subscriber? Yay! Consider sharing this post.
Jill, It took me such a long time to realize how my perfectionism affected my relationships. This post sheds light on some very important aspects within this issue and unpacks them in such a practical way so that we can understand. This spoke to me today and gives me food for thought. I have struggled with every. single. one. of these things. And still do. My mask has finally been flung to the side, but underneath, there’s still a whole lot of work to do! Thank you for helping me! Hugs!
Leslie, I know right? It feels good to breath after that mask has been so gently peeled away but that’s when the real work starts. God loves us so and is faithful to carry us to completion!
Hi Jill, I can really sense how much time and heart you put into this article. Thank you for sharing this for us recovering perfectionists. I recently experienced a great loss of a friend simply (or complicatedly, however you want to look at it) because I had isolated myself. No matter how I tried to explain my distance as being “not her, but me”, she was hurt. And the most hurtful thing for me was in being misunderstood. My friend was left to draw her own conclusions. It was the most painful rift I had ever experienced in a friendship, and I knew that if I had been honest in the beginning of the conflict, she would have been more understanding. I learned from that experience to give my friends the dignity of “trusting them with my imperfections”. Beautifully relevant, Jill, thank you.
Oh sister. I am so sorry. Losing a friend is such a painful experience compounded by being misunderstood. Thank you for sharing your story, I know that it resonates with others as well.
So so good!!! Thank you Jill!
Wow this is me!! its gotten so I won’t even leave the house without makeup on…I feel like if I don’t look perfectly put together people won’t like me. Even when I’m not going anywhere I have to have hair done and makeup on. This really helped!! Thank you!!
Diane, I totally understand and I thank you for sharing. It’s hard to let go of certain standards because we believe those standards and expectations are who we are. Keep fighting off perfectionism! Jill
Great post. I know I struggle with #2. Once someone pointed out that I was robbing others of the pleasure of helping. I enjoy helping other, why wouldn’t they like to return it.
Unfortunately, I have had to learn this the hard way. Life happened, and I had no choice I need help, I no longer could do it all alone.
I also got to a point where I no longer could cross my t’s and dot my i’s. A funny thing happened people like me a heck of a lot more.
Maree: isn’t that amazing! It’s so hard to accept help, to realize we can’t do it on our own. But how much more joyful and freeing when we accept help!
This is amazing!! Really eye opening and maked me think about the areas of my life that I have been either of these ways! Thank you so much for sharing!
Brenda, thank you for reading. All these little ways that perfectionism sneaks in… it’s so tricky.
Love this post, Jill. I’ve navigated every single one of these and fight against them often. It’s the fight to be “good.” It’s only by cultivating authentic and honest relationship with God and with others that I have overcome. It’s amazing what a difference it makes to remember that God loves us in spite of our flaws and so perfection is simply an illusion. Thank you for sharing this encouragement and wisdom!
Tiffany, Yes! God loves us so and calls us “very good” and not perfect. We are relieved from even having to shoot for perfection because we know the One already Perfect.
“God calls us to be real not ideal” Oh boy…that’s gonna stick in my brain!
I’m learning that asking for help gives someone else a chance to use their gifts.
Leaning on each other creates connection- instead of shame. (What I used to believe.)
Well done…but could you please stop reading my journal 🙂
Rebecca, Ha! All this stuff, unfortunately, comes from my own journal. Blergh! But God is so good that He allows us to ask for and receive help with zero shame as part of it. We’re learning this together right?
Okay. The pepper spray story is hilarious! Sounds like something I’d do. And, like pepper spray, perfectionism permeates every area of your life, making it hard to breathe. The only “cure” is in the perfect One. Great analogy.
Sheila, that evacuation was sooooooo embarrassing!!! Thank you for reading and reaching out. Let’s keep the pepper spray of perfectionism far away.
Thank you for taking the time to write all of this, Jill. I’ve been reading Love Idol by Jennifer Dukes Lee as well as Present Over Perfect by Shauna Neiquist and both have been challenging me (and helping me) to recognize how much perfectionism and the need for approval go hand in hand. I sometimes wonder why women seem to grapple with this stuff more than men… but that’s another topic. 🙂 We’re in this together! Appreciate your heart and insights, and I’ll not soon forget your brilliant pepper spray illustration. Yikes! x
Adriel, Those are two fantastic books aren’t they?!?!? Perfectionism and approval do go hand-in-hand. Glad that we are in this together. We can overcome this with Jesus and friends who struggle together with honesty and love. (And yes, that pepper spray situation was so incredibly embarrassing…)